Councillors refused Premier Inn's plan to knock down the 1850s Glegg Arms near Heswall by six votes to three, against officers' advice. Kingsmead pool was approved.
Councillors have refused permission to knock down the Glegg Arms. Wirral’s Planning Committee voted six to three against Whitbread’s plan to replace the building at the Gayton roundabout with 31 Premier Inn bedrooms. Planning officers had recommended approval.
Updated 25 October: the committee’s draft minutes for 7 October are now published. They record the Glegg Arms refusal and the reason, and a unanimous approval for the Kingsmead pool in Hoylake. The rest of this page is the report we published before the meeting.
The decision
The minutes give one reason for refusal. The proposal “would result in the total loss of the significance of a non-designated heritage asset”. The committee found the benefits had not been shown to outweigh that harm, citing national policy and Wirral Local Plan policy WD2E.
The motion to refuse was moved by the chair and seconded by Councillor Andrew Gardner. Councillor Jerry Williams left the room for the item, because he had sat on the panel that added the building to the local heritage list.
The Kingsmead pool scheme was approved unanimously, with conditions. They include the opening hours below and a cap of 26 square metres on the café.
The Glegg Arms: what is proposed
The application, APP/26/00734, covers the Glegg Arms on Chester Road, at the corner of Brimstage Road. The site sits in Heswall ward, about 650 metres from Heswall town centre.
The officer report says the oldest part of the building dates from around the 1850s. It traded as a Beefeater for more than ten years until mid-2024. It now serves as a restaurant for the neighbouring Premier Inn’s guests.
The plan would:
- demolish the Glegg Arms entirely
- build a new detached annexe to the hotel, with 31 bedrooms
- rebuild the front as a near-copy of the 1850s frontage, about 7.5 metres high against 6.7 metres today
- reuse the original coursed rubble stone and the stone sills and heads where possible
- put the dragon finial back on the front gable, and use natural slate instead of the current concrete tiles
- add a modern glazed link and a two- to three-storey block behind
Because the existing hotel would also be rearranged to fit breakfast facilities, the net gain is 24 bedrooms, the report says. The doors on the rebuilt front would be for show: they would serve as windows to hotel bedrooms.
An earlier application to demolish the building, made in 2024, was withdrawn.
The opposition
The report records:
- an online petition of 615 signatures asking for refusal, because the plan does not keep the historic facade
- 10 letters of objection, one in support and one neutral
- objections from the Heswall Society and Conservation Areas Wirral
- a call-in by ward councillor Kathy Hodson, on the grounds that it would mean the loss of a heritage asset
The Heswall Society’s objection runs to several pages. It argues that the building includes the office of a former public weighbridge, which it calls unique in Merseyside and Cheshire. It says the rebuilt front would be a “pastiche”, with plastic chimneys and cement panels in place of the stone stacks and timber framing.
The Society also disputes that keeping the front is unworkable. It says Whitbread has provided no costings for the options that would retain it. It says it found the restaurant serving dinner to several tables, with a sign welcoming non-residents, on 17 September.
Why officers recommended approval
The council’s heritage team first objected, then withdrew after Whitbread sent more evidence. Officers class the Glegg Arms as a non-designated heritage asset of low significance, because of how much it has been altered and extended.
Historic England assessed the building and found it did not meet the criteria for national listing. The report says Historic England has since confirmed it will not revisit that decision, after the Heswall Society asked it to.
Officers accept that demolition is the “total loss” of the asset. They conclude the loss is outweighed by the benefits, which they give “moderate weight”:
- a contribution to the local visitor economy
- more visitor accommodation in Wirral
- reuse of the site, and continuing its long hospitality use
The recommendation is to let the council’s chief planner approve the scheme, subject to conditions.
Kingsmead pool, Hoylake
The second item is the former Kingsmead school swimming pool on Carlton Lane, Hoylake, application APP/25/00915. The plan is to reopen it as a leisure and wellness centre with a café.
The committee deferred it on 13 August to look again at parking. The revised report sets out what has changed.
| Detail | |
|---|---|
| Parking off Carlton Lane | 13 spaces, 3 of them accessible |
| Extra parking | 10 spaces on the Bertram Drive school site, shared |
| Total | 23 spaces, against a requirement of 22 |
| Proposed hours | Mon to Sat 8am to 9pm; Sundays and bank holidays 9am to 7.30pm |
| Support | Petition of 1,142 signatures, plus 22 and then 92 letters |
| Objection | Petition of 32 people from 25 addresses, 19 letters, then further objections to the amended plans |
Objectors say Carlton Lane is a narrow, unadopted lane with no pavements or lighting, and cannot take the extra traffic. Supporters point to swimming for children and adults with special educational needs and disabilities. Officers recommend approval, with the hours secured by condition.
What it means for you
- The Glegg Arms stays, for now. Whitbread can appeal to the Planning Inspectorate against the refusal. For an application like this one, the deadline is normally six months from the date of the decision notice.
- Kingsmead can go ahead. The leisure and wellness centre on Carlton Lane has permission, subject to the conditions in the minutes.
- Committee votes like this are about to become rarer. From 31 October, a national scheme limits which applications councillors can decide. We explain it in our story on the extraordinary council meeting.
- Our Wirral planning news page tracks the borough’s bigger applications.
Have your say